Black tights are an essential wardrobe staple, especially as the cooler months approach. They can transform an outfit, making it chic and cozy at the same time. However, the challenge lies in finding a pair that combines durability, comfort, and style without succumbing to the dreaded rip. That’s why we’ve tested a range of black tights from various brands, including Spanx, Sheertex, and more, to bring you our top picks that will stand the test of time.
1. **Hue Super Opaque Tights with Control Top**: These tights have earned the title of ‘Best Overall’ for good reason. The Hue Super Opaque tights offer an impressive combination of fit, feel, and coverage. They fit true to size and provide excellent elasticity, stretching comfortably across the leg without sagging or pinching. The control top ensures a snug fit around the waist, providing support without discomfort. This nylon-spandex blend might feel thin to the touch, but it offers full coverage and, crucially, durability – resisting tears and snags throughout a full day of wear. Available in five sizes, they fit a wide range of body types, although they require hand washing, which could be a downside for some.
Product on Amazon: HUE Super Opaque Tights with Control Top
Price: $18.50
Rating: 4.5 with 11,353 ratings
Brand: HUE – A favorite for those seeking a combination of comfort and style.
2. **Commando Ultimate Opaque Matte Tights**: These tights stand out with their excellent stretch and full coverage. The Commando Ultimate Opaque tights provide a gentle yet effective support through their waistband. While not as robust as the Hue control top, they still prevent any slipping throughout the day. With a nylon-elastane blend offering a soft and warm feel, they are ideal for chilly days. Like many others, these tights require hand washing, but they come in four sizes, ensuring a good fit for various body types.
Product on Amazon: commando Women’s Control Top Ultimate Opaque Matte Tights
Price: $40.00
Rating: 4.1 with 68 ratings
Brand: commando
3. **Berkshire Cozy Hose Non-Control Top Tights**: Perfect for the coldest days, these fleece-lined tights are the warmest in our lineup. Their soft and fuzzy interior is perfect for anyone who values warmth. Despite their tendency to slip a bit during the day – a common issue with fleece-lined options – they provide an opaque look that remains consistent, even when bending or stretching. They fit people from five feet to almost six feet tall and weigh up to 240 pounds.
Product on Amazon: Berkshire Women’s Cozy Tight with Fleece-Lined Leg
Price: $12.24
Rating: 4.3 with 4,336 ratings
Brand: Berkshire
4. **Hanes X-Temp Blackout Control Top Tights**: Hanes offers a basic yet reliable option with these blackout tights. They are crafted with a thin elastic band, unlike other thicker waistband options, which means they might not stay perfectly in place all day. Nevertheless, they are soft, stretchy, and provide excellent coverage, making them comfortable for extended wear without snags.
Product on Amazon: Hanes Script Blackout Tights with X-Temp Technology with Control Top & Sheer Toe, Black
Price: $9.11
Rating: 4.5 with 5,357 ratings
Brand: Hanes – Perfect for the budget-conscious buyer who desires quality without sacrificing style.
5. **No-Nonsense Super Opaque Control Top Tights**: These tights feature a nylon-spandex blend that stretches well and fits comfortably. While the fabric feels less durable and more prone to runs, they still provide ample coverage for those seeking a basic, everyday pair. They should be handled with care, being hand wash only.
Product on Amazon: No Nonsense Women’s Super Opaque Control Top Tights
Price: $12.10
Rating: 4.4 with 32,654 ratings
Brand: No Nonsense
6. **Sheertex Classic Semi-Opaque Tights**: These tights are renowned for their durability, providing a firm fit that feels secure around the thighs and hips. While they may not be the softest option, their no-rip guarantee and machine-washable feature make them a must-have for anyone seeking long-lasting hosiery.
Product on Amazon: Sheertex Stubbornly Strong Sheer Rip-Resist Tights
Price: $19.99
Rating:3.2 with 445 ratings
Brand: Sheertex – A solid choice for those prioritizing strength and wearability.
7. **Moochi Women 80 Denier Semi-Opaque Tights**: These tights feature a lighter fabric that, while offering less warmth, ensures a comfortable fit and good coverage. Although they are a bit more prone to runs, their machine-washable quality and availability in two sizes make them a practical selection.
8. **Swedish Stockings Alma Rib Tights**: Made from a soft nylon and elastane mix, these tights are a softer choice but do not offer the most elastic fit. They tend to slip at the waist, but they are machine washable with recommended gentle care.
9. **Spanx Tight-End Tights**: When it comes to marrying style with resilience, the Spanx Tight-End Tights emerge as a frontrunner. Known for their snug fit, they hold your silhouette together without any discomfort, smoothly merging functionality with aesthetics. The nylon-elastane blend, typical of Spanx’s shapewear, offers a robust hold that prevents any slippage, making these tights an excellent choice for all-day wear. Despite their tight fit, which some might find a bit too firm for prolonged wear, their durability is unparalleled. You can rely on these tights to withstand the daily grind, remaining tear-free throughout. These tights come in a range of sizes from petite to plus, ensuring a perfect fit for every body type. Ideal for those looking for both warmth and style, the Spanx Tight-End Tights provide that extra layer of confidence, proving that fashion doesn’t have to be sacrificed for comfort. They might require a little patience to put on, especially for those with petite frames, but once in place, they exude an elegance that only Spanx can deliver.
Product on Amazon: SPANX Tight End Tights – Comfortable Tummy Control Shapewear – No Visible Panty Lines – Sheer Polka Dot – Very Black
Price: $32.00
Rating: 4.1 with 6 ratings
Brand: SPANX
10. **Wolford Mat Opaque 80 Tights**: If you’re seeking a blend of luxury and practicality, look no further than the Wolford Mat Opaque 80 Tights. These tights are crafted to offer a comfortable stretch with a luxurious feel. The nylon-elastane material provides a supportive fit, though it might feel a bit taut on the thighs and hips for some. Despite this, the waistband offers a pleasant support level, ensuring the tights stay up throughout the day. They boast a sophisticated opaque finish, making them perfect for daytime wear or an evening out. However, the fabric, while offering a snug fit, may not be the most durable in the long run, requiring careful handling. Available in multiple sizes, these tights offer a range of fitting options, although they are best suited for those who appreciate a tighter fit. The Wolford Mat Opaque shines in its ability to merge style with function, making it a favorite for many who value both aesthetic appeal and comfort.
Product on Amazon: Wolford Mat Opaque 80 Denier Tights Smooth Coverage and Lasting Comfort For Women
Price: $70.00
Rating:4.3 with 110 ratings
Brand: Wolford – An investment in luxury and comfort for those who appreciate premium hosiery.
11. **Snag Semi-Opaque Tights**: The Snag Semi-Opaque Tights are a revelation for those in search of exceptional stretch and comfort. With their unique polyamide, elastane, and cotton blend, these tights stretch effortlessly from the waistband to the toes, adapting to a variety of body shapes and sizes. Their legging-like feel offers unparalleled comfort, perfect for everyday wear. What sets these tights apart is their size inclusivity, catering to a wide range of heights and sizes. Despite their impressive stretch, they tend to lose some shape after extended wear, but a quick wash and dry will restore their original form. Their semi-opaque finish provides just the right amount of coverage while maintaining a fashionable look. These tights are perfect for those who prioritize comfort and stretch, offering a reliable choice for any wardrobe.
12. **Calzedonia Total Comfort Soft Touch Tights**: Calzedonia presents the Total Comfort Soft Touch Tights, a pair that truly lives up to its name. With a gentle, soft material that feels delightful against the skin, these tights offer a semi-opaque look, providing a perfectly balanced sheerness and opacity. Ideal for both casual and dressy occasions, these tights achieve a seamless blend of comfort and style. The supportive waistband ensures they remain securely in place, while the high-rise cut accentuates your silhouette beautifully. Their polyamide and elastane composition means they are resistant to most snags or tears. However, be mindful that they might not hold their original shape as well as some other options after extended wear. These tights are suitable for those who value a luxurious feel and a sophisticated, semi-opaque finish, making them a versatile addition to any outfit.
13. **Hanes Cellulite Smoothing Opaque Tights**: Offering a budget-friendly option without compromising on quality, the Hanes Cellulite Smoothing Opaque Tights are a must-have for those seeking comfort and affordability. These tights feature a comfortable waistband and light compression, providing a flattering fit for a variety of body shapes. While they are marketed as opaque, you might find them to be more semi-opaque, which can be a consideration depending on your outfit needs. Their length is friendly to petite figures, ensuring they fit well without any bunching. Despite a thinner waistband compared to other options, they maintain their shape and provide a reliable fit for daily activities. These tights are perfect for those who want a simple, effective solution for everyday wear, especially if you are looking for something versatile that can fit into a budget.
Product on Amazon: Hanes Women’s Leg Boost Cellulite Smoothing Pantyhose BB0001
Price: $11.28
Rating: 3.9 with 176 ratings
Brand: Hanes – Offers a smoothing effect while ensuring affordability for everyday wear.
14. **Everswe Soft Opaque Tights**: For those balancing affordability with quality, the Everswe Soft Opaque Tights are an excellent choice. Featuring a comfortable flexible waistband, these tights are designed to be incredibly stretchy while maintaining their shape over time, and they come in an array of vibrant colors to liven up your wardrobe. Despite having a narrower waistband compared to other options, they are a dependable pick for stylish budget-conscious shoppers.
Product on Amazon: EVERSWE 3 Pairs Women’s Sheer Tights 20D, High Waist Control Top Pantyhose Hosiery
Price: $9.99
Rating: 3.9 with 1,890 ratings
Brand: EVERSWE
15. **Commando Sexy Sheer Tights**: Commanding attention with their elegant design, the Commando Sexy Sheer Tights are perfect for those days when you want to add a hint of allure to your ensemble. These tights offer a delicate sheerness that enhances the overall look, making them suitable for pairing with skirts or dresses. A standout feature is the high-rise lace waistband, adding a touch of glamour and offering a comfortable fit that feels more like lingerie than traditional tights. However, their thin fabric could be more prone to holes and snags, so they require careful handling. These are ideal for those special occasions when you want your tights to make a statement.
Product on Amazon: commando Women’s The Sexy Sheer Tights
Price: $38.00
Rating: 3.7 with 132 ratings
Brand: commando – Designed for those who want to feel sexy without compromising on comfort.
16. **A New Day Blackout Tights**: Available at Target, the A New Day Blackout Tights are a top pick for those seeking an opaque finish that doesn’t compromise on comfort. These tights are perfect for layering during the cooler months, lending a sleek, polished look to any ensemble. Their high-rise design and supportive waistband ensure they stay in place throughout the day, providing both coverage and warmth. They offer an affordable option while maintaining the style and functionality required for daily wear. Suitable for a range of body types, these tights are an excellent addition to any wardrobe, aligning with the needs of those who appreciate both form and function.
As we conclude our stylish exploration of black tights, it’s evident that finding the right pair can elevate your outfits while ensuring the durability needed for everyday life. From the strong Spanx to the luxurious Wolford, these selections cater to various preferences and occasions, promising to keep you chic and comfortable, and showcasing the ideal blend of fashion and practicality.
Related posts:
The Best Black Tights of 2025
The 10 Best Black Tights, Tested by PEOPLE Editors
The 10 Very Best Black Tights
