As we step into 2025, it’s time to reassess the beauty trends that help us maintain a fresh and youthful appearance. However, some eye makeup techniques from the past may not be doing us any favors and could actually make us look older. In this article, we explore the common mistakes with these outdated methods and explain why it’s best to leave them behind.
1. **Harsh Black eyeliner**: Over the years, the allure of a bold, defined eye has drawn many to reach for black eyeliner. While impactful, this can often create a stark contrast that emphasizes fine lines and can make eyes appear smaller and more tired. Instead of enhancing your features, a harsh black liner can inadvertently bring attention to imperfections, especially if it’s applied heavily on the lower lash line.
The modern alternative is to opt for softer shades like brown or charcoal, which offer definition without the harshness. These shades blend seamlessly, providing a more natural enhancement that opens up the eyes and offers a softer, more youthful appearance. Makeup artists now recommend a smudged or diffused liner look to maintain the desired intensity without the aging effect.
Product on Amazon: Revlon ColorStay Pencil Eyeliner with Built-in Sharpener, Waterproof, Smudgeproof, Longwearing Eye Makeup with Ultra-Fine Tip, Black, 0.01 oz
Brand: Visit the REVLON Store
Price: 6.77 USD
Rating: 4.5 Total reviews: 33195
Color: Black
Item Form: Pencil
Finish Type: Matte
Special Feature: Waterproof
Top Review from US: “Great product”
Shopping on Amzon >>
Read more about: 10 Makeup Mistakes to Dodge for a Youthful Glow, According to Top MUAs
2. **Over-Plucked Eyebrows**: A trend that peaked in the late 90s and early 2000s, over-plucked eyebrows can unfortunately age your face. Thin brows can make your features appear harsher and less defined, often drawing unwanted attention away from your eyes and towards the forehead.
The shift towards fuller, natural brows has been revolutionary in beauty circles. Embracing your natural brow shape and using products like brow gels and pencils to fill in sparse areas can rejuvenate your look. Fuller brows frame the face better, offering a more youthful and balanced appearance. The key is to keep them well-groomed but not overly manicured, allowing for a softer frame around the eyes.
Product on Amazon: Eyebrow Serum for Over Plucked Brows – 0.35 fl oz – Rosemary Infused – Eyebrow Potion
Brand: Brand: Rooted Earth Farm
Price: 21.99 USD
Rating: 3.8 Total reviews: 14
Top Review from US: “So I haven’t tried this yet but the packaging and thank you card was CLASS ACT! Thank you so much looking forward to starting tonight!! xo.”
Shopping on Amzon >>
Read more about: 10 Makeup Mistakes to Dodge for a Youthful Glow, According to Top MUAs
3. **Frosty Eyeshadow**: In the quest to make eyes pop, frosty eyeshadows were once the go-to. This shimmering formula, however, can easily settle into fine lines, accentuating wrinkles and creating a dated look.
Current beauty trends favor matte and satin finishes that create a smoother, more polished look without drawing attention to imperfections. These modern textures help provide a flattering canvas that highlights your natural eye shape and color beautifully. Makeup artists recommend selecting shades that harmonize with your skin tone for a fresh and radiant finish.
Product on Amazon: ColourPop Super Shock Shadow – High-Pigment, Crème-Powder Eye Makeup – Single Glitter Eyeshadow with Zero Fallout and Unique Bouncy Texture – Metallic Baby Blue Eyeshadow – Moon Daisy (0.07 oz)
Brand: Visit the Colourpop Store
Price: 7 USD
Rating: 4.1 Total reviews: 114
Color: Moon Daisy – metallic baby blue with silver pinpoints
Item Form: Powder
Finish Type: Metallic
Special Feature: Long lasting
Top Review from US: “Exactly what I thought it was going to be. The color is beautiful.”
Shopping on Amzon >>
Read more about: A Makeup Artist’s Guide to Flawless Makeup on Crepey Eyelids
4. **Heavy Mascara on Lower Lashes**: Applying a thick coat of mascara to your lower lashes might seem like a way to open up your eyes, but it can actually weigh them down, creating shadows and emphasizing under-eye circles.
Instead, opt for a waterproof formula applied sparingly on the lower lashes, or consider skipping it altogether. By focusing on curling your upper lashes and generously applying mascara there, you can create a lifted effect that makes your eyes appear more awake and bright. This simple change not only enhances your gaze but also contributes to a more youthful, lively look.
Product on Amazon: Pixi Beauty Lower Lash Mascara, Water-resistant Formula, Slim Brush With Short Bristles, Vitamin E & Panthenol for Lashes, 3.2ml 0.11fl oz
Brand: Visit the Pixi Store
Price: 11 USD
Rating: 3.8 Total reviews: 67
Color: Black
Product Benefits: Lengthening
Special Feature: Not Tested On Animals
Material Type Free: Paraben Free
Top Review from US: “FINALLY I found a mascara for doing bottom lashes!!! Where has this been all my life?It’s hard to leave a review for a product like this because of what it is, but I’ll try. The brush is just as shown in the pictures very very small. It is extremely easy to apply mascara to every single lash. I did not have any irritation or burning from the Mascara, I actually used it on my lashes for the first coat and it was nice to be able to get to the lashes on the inside of your eye with the big bulky mascara wand.”
Shopping on Amzon >>
Read more about: Timeless Eye Makeup Tricks for Women Over 50: Enhance Your Beauty, Shed the Years
5. **The Power of Primer**: A game-changer in modern eye makeup is the use of a good primer. Eye primers create a smooth canvas that not only enhances the vibrancy of your eyeshadow but also ensures longevity. By preventing creasing, it keeps your makeup flawless all day. Imagine your eyeshadow looking as fresh at 8 PM as it did at 8 AM. This modern necessity has become a staple in makeup kits everywhere.
A primer can work wonders, especially for those with oily lids. It acts as a barrier to control oil and keeps your makeup from sliding off or gathering into lines. Makeup artists suggest looking for primers that are lightweight and offer some level of hydration to balance out dryness, giving your eyes a more youthful, rested appearance.
Product on Amazon: e.l.f. Power Grip Primer, Gel-Based & Hydrating Face Primer For Smoothing Skin & Gripping Makeup, Moisturizes & Primes, 0.811 Fl Oz (24 ml.)
Brand: Visit the e.l.f. Store
Price: 7.75 USD
Rating: 4.6 Total reviews: 27915
Product Benefits: Hydrating
Coverage: Translucent
Item Form: Gel
Skin Type: All
Top Review from US: “Sometimes you need more than a little moisturizer prior to applying foundation/concealer and this definitely does the trick! I noticed using this primer gives me more of an airbrushed look. It’s just smooth looking. No cakiness nor does it dry my skin out. Just do your normal skin care routine, apply moisturizer then the primer. The rest is history lol. You’ll be glad you purchased this. :)”
Shopping on Amzon >>
Read more about: Timeless Beauty: Avoid These Makeup Mistakes That Instantly Age Women Over 50
6. **Unblended Eye Shadow**: Noticeable lines from unblended eyeshadow can make your makeup seem harsh and unfinished, inadvertently aging your appearance.
Blending is key to a polished, youthful appearance. Use a soft, fluffy brush to blend out harsh lines and ensure a seamless transition between colors. This technique softens the overall look, creating a more harmonious and flattering effect that enhances your natural beauty.
Product on Amazon: Clinique All About Shadow Duo Eye Shadow Makeup | Safe For Sensitive Eyes
Price: 31 USD
Rating: 4.6 Total reviews: 455
Color: AF Neutral Territory – Shimmer
Item Form: Powder
Finish Type: Shimmery
Special Feature: Crease Proof
Top Review from US: “This is a great product have used it for a while. It stays on a long time with no creases. Pretty colors too.”
Shopping on Amzon >>
Read more about: 10 Aging Makeup Mistakes That Instantly Add Years To Your Look
7.**Glitter Overload**: While glitter can add a playful touch to your makeup, going overboard can age you by drawing attention to fine lines and creating a messy, unfocused look.
For a more sophisticated sparkle, choose products with finely milled shimmer. These provide a subtle luminosity that catches the light without overpowering your features. Experts suggest applying it strategically on the inner corners of the eyes or the center of the lid for a youthful glow.
Read more about: Eye Makeup Blunders That Sneakily Add Years To Your Look
8. **Over-Contoured Eyes**: While contoured eyes were once all the rage, this heavy application can sometimes result in a theatrical look that can make you appear older instead of enhancing your natural beauty.
Instead of heavy contouring, focus on subtle shading that enhances your eye shape. Use neutral tones to add depth and dimension without overwhelming your features. This approach ensures that your makeup enhances rather than detracts from your natural beauty, offering a more youthful and vibrant look.
9. **Ignoring the Waterline**: The often-neglected waterline, the area closest to your eye, can make or break your eye makeup. Dark pencil here might seem like an easy way to achieve a sultry vibe, but it can make your eyes appear smaller and more closed off.
To achieve a more youthful and open look, opt for a nude or white pencil on the waterline. This simple change can make a significant difference, brightening the eyes and creating the illusion of larger, more inviting peepers. It’s a small tweak with a big impact, recommended by professionals.
Read more about: 10 Eyeshadow Tricks After 50 for a Flawless Look
10. **Lift With Light Liner**: A light eyeliner can work wonders in opening up your eyes and lifting your overall look. A delicate line of white or beige along the upper lash line instantly enhances your eye shape, while pairing it with a darker shade on the lower lash line offers a soft yet striking contrast.
Makeup experts champion this technique as it highlights the natural contours of your eyelid without the harsh effect that darker liners can produce. By strategically manipulating light and shadow, you can achieve the illusion of larger, brighter eyes—essential for that youthful radiance.
Read more about: 10 Eyeshadow Tricks After 50 for a Flawless Look
11. **Mascara for a Fluttery Finish**: Today’s beauty philosophy emphasizes a natural, fluttery lash look. This can be accomplished by concentrating mascara on your upper lashes, creating a natural lift while avoiding potential clumps on the lower lashes.
Opting for mascaras that lengthen and separate rather than create bulk is key. Curl your lashes first to enhance this effect, and you’ll find your eyes appearing bigger and more awake. It’s a simple trick with stunning results, steering clear of the heavy, dated mascara looks of the past.
Read more about: My $400 Beauty Haul: Hits and Misses from a Makeup Artist’s Perspective
12. **Embrace the Monochromatic Look**: Utilizing a single color palette across your eyes, cheeks, and lips creates a harmonious and chic appearance. This trend has gained massive popularity due to its ability to simplify the makeup process while still delivering a modern and cohesive look.
Choosing a soft, neutral shade that complements your skin tone can enhance your features subtly, giving off a polished vibe without looking overdone. It’s the ultimate go-to for everyday wear, providing a put-together appearance that’s fresh and youthful.
Read more about: From Daring to Dashing: 15 Men’s Outfits Women Can’t Resist
In embracing these modern techniques, you open the door to a world of youthful, vibrant beauty. It’s about finding what works for you and letting go of the outdated practices that no longer serve your best look. Celebrate your individuality with looks that are as fresh and dynamic as you are. Here’s to a stunning 2025, full of life and beauty!
Related posts:
65 Best Beauty Products of 2025, According to Vogue’s Beauty Team
8 “Outdated” Makeup Trends It’s Time To Officially Retire In 2025
2 Aging & Outdated Makeup Trends Pro MUAs Say Women Over 40 Should Leave Behind In 2024 To Look Younger
