Mastering Eyeshadow After 40: Hues to Avoid and Flattering Alternatives

Mastering Eyeshadow After 40: Hues to Avoid and Flattering Alternatives
A woman's eyelid is delicately painted with glamorous shimmery eyeshadow and mascara.
Photo by Magda Ehlers on Pexels

Stepping into the world of makeup after 40 is an exciting opportunity for rediscovery and personal expression, allowing us to celebrate beauty infused with our unique life experiences. As we navigate this artistic realm, it’s important to recognize that some shades may no longer flatter us as they once did. Esteemed makeup artists suggest there are particular eyeshadow colors that should be retired from your collection as we age, and this guide will delve into these shades and the rationale behind their departure.

1. Metallic Red: A color as bold and daring as metallic red can be the epitome of high fashion makeup. This shade can add years to your face by making your eyes look tired, irritated, and generally unwell. The allure of metallic might be tempting, especially with its trending appearance on BeautyTok and Pinterest. However, for those of us gracefully transitioning through our forties and beyond, metallic eyeshadows, particularly in red, can be unforgiving to textured or mature skin. Avoiding metallic eyeshadows on older skin due to their harshness on textured and wrinkled complexions.

2. Bright Crimson: Keeping away from bright crimson shades is a wise choice, as echoed by beauty experts. The natural redness of our blood is mirrored in this shade, often unintentionally presenting a look of crying, allergies, or general discomfort. Instead of enhancing our natural beauty, this color risks adding an unintentional tiredness to our expression. Red eyeshadow might inadvertently suggest that “something unpleasant is going on,” a sentiment no one wishes to convey through their makeup.

Close-up portrait of a young woman with striking makeup and short hair, embodying a modern and edgy style.
Photo by aydin sefidi on Pexels

3. Sparkly Sheer: Shimmery, sheer eyeshadows have their place in youthful exuberance but might not benefit mature skin. The tiny reflective particles in these shadows can draw undue attention to fine lines and wrinkles, which we usually aim to soften, not highlight. The outcome can often be counterproductive, accentuating lines rather than concealing them, as Jackson warns.

4. Deep Purple: While deep purple can evoke a sense of regal elegance, it often has the unintended consequence of making the eyes appear sunken or fatigued. The richness of this color can sometimes overshadow the natural radiance of more mature skin, lending an unflattering aged appearance instead of enhancing our beauty.

5.Vivid Blue: This energetic hue can be captivating, yet for older eyes, vivid blue can clash with the natural changes in skin tone that occur with age. Over 40, the skin’s undertones may shift, and blue can struggle to complement these new nuances, often leading to a jarring rather than harmonious look.

6. Neon Green: Neon colors, while fun and vibrant, can overpower the subtlety and sophistication that often accompanies mature beauty. Neon green, in particular, might not blend seamlessly with the natural elegance sought in makeup over 40.

7. Bold Black: A classic choice for creating dramatic eye looks, bold black eyeshadow can harshly accentuate features, inadvertently adding years to our appearance. This striking shade tends to make the eyes look smaller and more recessed, which is at odds with the softer effect we generally aim for in our beauty routines.

8. Glittering Gold: Gold, though synonymous with glamour, can sometimes reflect light in ways that accentuate wrinkles. If not applied carefully, it can create a spotlight effect on areas one might prefer to minimize, rather than highlight.

Stylish woman in black puffer jacket posing with lights in an urban setting.
Photo by Alax Matias on Pexels

But what kinds of eyeshadow can flatter our beauty rather than aging us,here is some recommendations from makeup artisits.

1. Soft Taupe: As we gracefully venture into our forties, embracing shadows that enhance our natural skin tone becomes paramount. Soft taupe, a color that lives harmoniously between gray and brown, is a wonderful choice. It provides just enough depth to bring out your eyes without overpowering their natural beauty. Do not compete with your eyes natural color but rather complement it. This shade softly accentuates your eyes, giving them a subtle definition perfect for mature skin.

Soft taupe is a wonderfully versatile shade that harmonizes beautifully with various skin tones and eye colors, making it a must-have in any makeup collection. This color can be applied delicately for a daytime look or layered for added intensity in the evening, showcasing its ability to frame the eyes with a gentle sophistication that remains timeless, free from the constraints of passing trends.

2. Earthy Bronze: This warm and elegant shade captures the perfect balance of subtle shimmer without overwhelming the eyelid, instead imparting a soft glow that accentuates natural beauty. For women over 40, earthy bronze is an ideal choice for radiance without excess shine, enhancing your features gracefully.

Thanks to its harmonious blend of brown and gold, earthy bronze transitions effortlessly from casual to formal settings. This forgiving shade can be applied precisely for a polished look or diffused for a smoky effect, making it an incredibly adaptable color that suits every occasion equally well.

3. Warm Peach: When it comes to adding a touch of color that feels fresh and vibrant, warm peach stands out. It’s a delightful alternative to harsh reds or pinks, offering a universally flattering hue that brightens the eyes and complements mature skin.

Expert makeup artists advise using warm peach to “add a youthful glow without the stark contrast of brighter hues.” The softness of peach provides a natural warmth that enhances the eyes, making them appear more lively and engaged.

This shade works well as a transitional color that can be used as a base or a pop of color on the lid. Its gentle undertones ensure that the result is always graceful, never garish.

Product on Amazon: REVLON ColorStay Day to Night Eyeshadow Quad, Longwear Shadow Palette with Transitional Shades and Buttery Soft Feel, Crease & Smudge Proof, 565 Pretty, 0.16 Oz
Price: $6.15
Rating: 4.3 with 352 ratings
Brand: REVLON

Buy on Amazon>>>

4. Soft Lavender: This enchanting yet understated shade can add a lovely soft focus to your eyes. Unlike darker purples that may cast unwanted shadows, soft lavender provides a delicate hint of color that flatters and enhances without overpowering your natural beauty.

Makeup artists appreciate lavender for its “ability to neutralize the yellows in the skin,” providing a serene, fresh look that is both contemporary and timeless.

When applied with a light touch, soft lavender can create the illusion of larger, more expressive eyes, making it a fantastic choice for both daytime and evening looks. Its versatility allows it to complement a variety of outfits and occasions, ensuring you always look effortlessly chic.

Product on Amazon: ColourPop Lilac You A Lot Shadow Palette – Purple Shadow Palette with Metallic and Matte Finishes – High-Pigment Makeup with a Long-Wearing Formula (0.3 oz)
Price: $14
Rating: 4.2 with 180 ratings
Brand: ColourPop

Buy on Amazon>>>

5. Champagne Gold: Champagne gold is a sophisticated alternative to glittering gold, offering a luminous finish without the intensity of full-on sparkle. It’s the perfect balance of shine and subtlety, making it an excellent choice for adding a touch of glamour to mature eyes.

Champagne gold can accentuate the eyes’ natural sparkle, without drawing attention to fine lines This shade is ideal for highlighting the inner corner of the eyes or the brow bone, providing just the right amount of luster.

Appropriate for any time of day, champagne gold translates effortlessly from casual brunches to elegant dinners, providing a little luxury while remaining tastefully understated.

Detailed close-up of a woman's blue eye, showcasing makeup and eyelashes.
Photo by Lisa Fotios on Pexels

Product on Amazon: Julep Eyeshadow 101 Crème-to-Powder Waterproof Eyeshadow Stick – Champagne Shimmer – Long-Lasting, Crease-Proof, Medium Golden-Beige Shimmer Cream Eyeshadow with Built-in Smudger
Price: $10.8
Rating: 4.3 with 50,511 ratings
Brand: Julep

Buy on Amazon>>>

Choosing the right eyeshadow shade is essential in transforming your overall look, adding both elegance and charm to your appearance. The secret lies in selecting colors that enhance your natural beauty rather than overshadow it, so step confidently into your makeup journey and explore these expert-approved alternatives that promise timeless elegance and endless creative possibilities.

Related posts:
Makeup artist shares ‘unflattering’ lipstick colours for women over 40

Leave a Reply